Magikarp #89 Mysterious Treasures

Common • 89/123

$20.12

+$3.46 (+20.78%) past 6M

Ungraded

$20.12

Grade 7

$—

Grade 8

$—

Grade 9

$—

PSA 10

$—

Details

Set: Mysterious Treasures
Number: 89/123
Rarity: Common
Type: Water
Language: English
Manufacturer: Pokemon
HP: 30
Stage: Basic
Weakness: L+10
Retreat Cost: 1

Recent Sales

Sale Date	Title	Price
Aug 1, 2026	UngradedPokemon TCG Magikarp 89/123 Mysterious Treasures NM	$2.99
Aug 1, 2026	UngradedPokemon Magikarp Mysterious Treasures 89/123 Common Reverse Holo 30 HP EN 89/123	$20.00
Jul 31, 2026	UngradedMagikarp 89/123 Common Mysterious Treasures Pokemon Cards 89/123	$1.99
Jul 31, 2026	UngradedMagikarp 89/123 Mysterious Treasures Pokemon Card 89/123	$2.95
Jul 29, 2026	UngradedPokemon Card - Magikarp Mysterious Treasures 89/123 2007 Common Lightly Played 89/123	$2.50
Jul 29, 2026	PSA 9Magikarp 89/123 From Mysterious Treasures (2007) CGC 9 Eng Pokémon 89/123	$12.00
Jul 28, 2026	UngradedMagikarp Common Pokémon TCG Mysterious Treasures 89/123 MP	$2.84
Jul 28, 2026	UngradedMagikarp 89/123 Common Mysterious Treasures Pokemon Lightly Played 89/123	$2.99
Jul 27, 2026	UngradedModerately Played · 2 sold	$0.51
Jul 27, 2026	UngradedLightly Played · 1 sold	$1.10
Jul 26, 2026	UngradedMagikarp 89/123 Mysterious Treasures Reverse Holo Pokémon TCG - LP 89/123	$4.99
Jul 26, 2026	UngradedModerately Played · 1 sold	$5.41
Jul 25, 2026	UngradedPokemon TCG Magikarp Common Mysterious Treasures 89/123 89/123	$2.50
Jul 24, 2026	UngradedLightly Played · 2 sold	$1.00
Jul 24, 2026	UngradedModerately Played · 1 sold	$0.63
Jul 24, 2026	UngradedNear Mint · 1 sold	$1.63
Jul 23, 2026	UngradedLightly Played · 1 sold	$24.99
Jul 21, 2026	UngradedModerately Played · 1 sold	$0.59
Jul 21, 2026	UngradedNear Mint · 1 sold	$1.61
Jul 21, 2026	UngradedMagikarp 89/123 \| DP Mysterious Treasures \| 2007 Vintage Pokemon TCG Card \| LP 89/123	$3.70
Jul 20, 2026	UngradedLP Nintendo Pokémon TCG Magikarp 89/123 Mysterious Treasures Common 2007 Vintage 89/123	$4.04
Jul 18, 2026	UngradedModerately Played · 1 sold	$0.50
Jul 18, 2026	UngradedLightly Played · 1 sold	$0.99
Jul 17, 2026	UngradedLightly Played · 2 sold	$1.01
Jul 17, 2026	UngradedModerately Played · 1 sold	$0.50
Jul 15, 2026	UngradedLightly Played · 2 sold	$0.98
Jul 15, 2026	UngradedModerately Played · 1 sold	$0.50
Jul 14, 2026	UngradedLightly Played · 1 sold	$0.93
Jul 14, 2026	UngradedModerately Played · 1 sold	$0.50
Jul 14, 2026	UngradedHeavily Played · 1 sold	$0.49
Jul 14, 2026	UngradedLightly Played · 2 sold	$13.32
Jul 13, 2026	UngradedMagikarp 89/123 Common Mysterious Treasures Pokemon Reverse Holo 89/123	$7.99
Jul 13, 2026	UngradedMagikarp 89/123 Common Mysterious Treasures Pokemon LP 89/123	$1.99
Jul 12, 2026	UngradedNear Mint · 1 sold	$1.60
Jul 12, 2026	UngradedLightly Played · 3 sold	$12.82
Jul 3, 2026	UngradedNear Mint · 1 sold	$39.99
Jun 30, 2026	UngradedHeavily Played · 1 sold	$10.00
Jun 21, 2026	UngradedHeavily Played · 1 sold	$4.84
Jun 20, 2026	UngradedHeavily Played · 1 sold	$4.84
Jun 18, 2026	PSA 82007 POKEMON DIAMOND & PEARL MYSTERIOUS TREASURES MAGIKARP-REVERSE FOIL PSA 8 #89	$196.00
Jun 17, 2026	UngradedModerately Played · 1 sold	$14.00
Jun 15, 2026	UngradedModerately Played · 1 sold	$14.00
Jun 3, 2026	UngradedHeavily Played · 1 sold	$4.74
Jun 2, 2026	UngradedHeavily Played · 1 sold	$4.74
May 28, 2026	UngradedHeavily Played · 1 sold	$4.86
May 27, 2026	UngradedHeavily Played · 1 sold	$4.86
May 23, 2026	PSA 9Pokemon Magikarp - CGC 9 2007 Mysterious Treasures 89/123 Reverse Holo - Blue 🔥 89/123	$99.90
May 7, 2026	PSA 92007 POKEMON MYSTERIOUS TREASURES #89 MAGIKARP CGC 9	$11.50
May 7, 2026	UngradedModerately Played · 1 sold	$5.84
May 6, 2026	UngradedLightly Played · 1 sold	$6.19
May 6, 2026	UngradedModerately Played · 1 sold	$5.84
May 4, 2026	UngradedLightly Played · 1 sold	$6.19
May 2, 2026	PSA 92007 POKEMON MYSTERIOUS TREASURES #89 MAGIKARP CGC 9	$17.00
May 1, 2026	UngradedModerately Played · 2 sold	$3.94
Apr 30, 2026	UngradedHeavily Played · 2 sold	$5.30
Apr 28, 2026	UngradedHeavily Played · 2 sold	$5.30
Apr 28, 2026	UngradedModerately Played · 1 sold	$4.95
Apr 28, 2026	UngradedLightly Played · 3 sold	$14.99
Apr 25, 2026	PSA 9CGC 9 MINT Magikarp 2007 Mysterious Treasures 89/123 Reverse Holo Pokemon Card 89/123	$99.99
Apr 25, 2026	UngradedModerately Played · 1 sold	$9.68
Apr 16, 2026	UngradedModerately Played · 2 sold	$3.95
Apr 6, 2026	PSA 86079 Magikarp 2007 Pokemon Diamond & Pearl Mysterious Treasures #89/123 CGC 8.5 89/123	$14.50
Apr 2, 2026	UngradedNear Mint · 1 sold	$9.99
Apr 1, 2026	PSA 82007 POKEMON MYSTERIOUS TREASURES #89 MAGIKARP CGC 8	$12.50
Mar 29, 2026	UngradedModerately Played · 2 sold	$3.72
Mar 29, 2026	UngradedLightly Played · 1 sold	$16.66
Feb 9, 2026	PSA 82007 Pokemon Magikarp Mysterious Treasures Reverse Holo 89/123 CGC 8.5 NM+ RARE! 89/123	$44.99
Dec 28, 2025	PSA 8CGC 8.5 Magikarp Mysterious Treasures 89/123 Reverse Holo Graded Pokemon Card 89/123	$46.99
Sep 4, 2025	PSA 82007 POKEMON DIAMOND & PEARL MYSTERIOUS TREASURES MAGIKARP-REVERSE FOIL PSA 8 #89	$69.00
Feb 3, 2025	PSA 9CGC 9 MINT Magikarp Mysterious Treasures 89/123 Reverse Holo Graded Pokemon Card 89/123	$69.99
Oct 22, 2024	PSA 92007 Pokemon Mysterious Treasures #89/123 Reverse Holo Magikarp CGC 9 MINT	$31.15
Oct 13, 2024	PSA 8PSA 8 MAGIKARP 89/123 2007 POKEMON TCG DIAMOND & PEARL MYSTERIOUS TREASURES	$16.13

Showing 72 sales · click a row to view the listing

Ungraded Magikarp #89 Prices By Condition

Ungraded: $20.12
Near Mint: $36.79
Lightly Played: $16.35
Moderately Played: $8.03
Heavily Played: $5.88

Each condition is a recency-weighted average of recent sales (newer sales count more) — not a median. The overall Ungraded figure reflects Near Mint/Lightly Played sales.

Full Price Guide: Magikarp #89 (Pokemon Mysterious Treasures)

Grade	PSA Pop	CGC Pop	Total Pop	Price
5	—	1	1	—
6	1	2	3	—
7	4	6	10	—
8	5	9	14	—
9	10	8	18	—
10	—	8	8	—

Population counts are the number of copies PSA and CGC have graded at each grade (Total = PSA + CGC). Prices are recency-weighted averages of recent graded sales — not a median.

Add to Collection

Total

$—

Details

Set: Mysterious Treasures
Number: 89/123
Rarity: Common
Type: Water
Language: English
Manufacturer: Pokemon
HP: 30
Stage: Basic
Weakness: L+10
Retreat Cost: 1